HealthcareStatewide NewsLawsuit Filed Against Gov. Abbott Over Nursing Home ‘Edicts,’ Alleges Constitutional Violations

The lawsuit lists multiple defendants and alleges constitutional violations, elder abuse, and violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
September 16, 2020
A married couple as well as a mother and daughter pairing have sued Gov. Greg Abbott and two nursing homes over allegations of abuse and illegal executive orders.

The lawsuit was filed in Travis County’s 53rd Judicial District Court in Austin, where Democratic Judge Scott Jenkins presides.

Represented by Arlington attorney Warren Norred, the plaintiffs’ allegations include elder abuse as well as violations of the Texas Constitution, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and Medicaid guidelines.

The plaintiffs also make accusations against Texas Health and Human Services Commission Director Cecile Young.

“After weeks of working with folks who are suffering with the loss of loved ones due only to Gov. Abbott’s top-down edicts shutting down visits to nursing homes, the relatives of loved ones imprisoned by the Governor have had enough,” Norred said in a post on his firm’s website.

The Texan Tumbler

“The bottom line of this suit is that Governor Abbott and his band of merry administrators are violating constitutional and statutory rights of Plaintiffs by prohibiting essential family visitors, damaging the health of residents in these facilities, and costing precious time to the residents and their families.”

In an effort to protect the elderly from contracting COVID-19, Abbott barred visitation to nursing homes in an executive order on March 19, which is attached as Exhibit D in the original petition.

Among the plaintiffs is Marcy Renneberg, whose mother, Aline, is a resident of San Gabriel Rehabilitation and Care Center in Round Rock.

Renneberg claims that the defendants’ restrictions on visitation to nursing homes inhibited her ability to care for her mother, who lost her husband in July to COVID-19.

The remaining plaintiffs are Wanda and Leland Webb. Mrs. Webb cares for her husband, who is a resident of Pine Arbor Nursing Home in Silsbee.

“Leland Webb has now tested positive for COVID-19, which must have come into Pine Arbor via a staff member or employee or maybe a vending machine delivery man, since no family members are able to enter the facility,” the suit reads.

“Clearly, the policies defined in GA-28 are not preventing viral spread. They are, however, demonstrably hurting the very people they were intended to safeguard.”

GA-28 refers to another one of Abbott’s executive orders, which he issued on June 26, that re-upped the ban on visiting nursing home residents.

As part of his justification for the order, Abbott invoked Section 418.011 of the Texas Government Code, which states, “The governor is responsible for meeting: (1) the dangers to the state and the people presented by disasters; and (2) disruptions to the state and people caused by energy emergencies.”

The defendants had not replied to a request for comment by the time of publishing.

The text of the lawsuit filed is below.


Disclosure: Unlike almost every other media outlet, The Texan is not beholden to any special interests, does not apply for any type of state or federal funding, and relies exclusively on its readers for financial support. If you’d like to become one of the people we’re financially accountable to, click here to subscribe.

Get “KB's Hot Take”

A free bi-weekly commentary on current events by Konni Burton.

Hayden Sparks

Hayden Sparks is a senior reporter for The Texan and a lifelong resident of the Lone Star State. He has coached competitive speech and debate and has been involved in politics since a young age. One of Hayden's favorite quotes is by Sam Houston: "Texas has yet to learn submission to any oppression, come from what source it may."